That’s the declaration from a federal district court – dismissing a lawsuit filed by the American Civil Liberties Union against Dixie County, Fla. and ending a six-year legal battle.
The ACLU sued the county after they allowed a private citizen to erect a six-ton monument of the Ten Commandments atop the steps of the courthouse.
A 75-year-old North Carolina man, who happens to be an ACLU member, objected to the monument – which led to the lawsuit.
Liberty Counsel represented the county and challenged the ACLU’s standing to bring a suit on behalf of a member who lives hundreds of miles away from the monument.”
Senior District Judge Maurice Paul dismissed the case after the ACLU admitted that their client did not plan to buy property in Dixie County and therefore lacks standing to sue.
In addition to dismissing the case, the ACLU will be responsible for several thousand dollars in court costs.
“This was a great victory,” Liberty Counsel Founder Mathew Staver told Fox News. “What it says about the bully tactics by the ACLU is that if you resist them, you can win.”
“The usual way they win is my intimidation or default – when the government officials cave in under the threat of a lawsuit,” Staver said.
The county had a policy that allowed private citizens to put up different kinds of displays – including the religious monuments.
Harry Mihet, senior litigation counsel for Liberty Counsel, said the ACLU got caught with its hands in the “constitutional cookie jar.”
“It’s prolonged campaign against the good citizens of Dixie County has come to a screeching halt,” he said. “In getting kicked out of court, the ACLU has learned that it cannot impose its San Francisco values upon a small town in Florida – using a phantom member from North Carolina.
Quote: Sanguine wrote in post #2A bit of sanity in the wilderness.
yes but not as much "sanity" as I'd like to have seen. the case was simply thrown out due to 'lack of standing' on the part of the one who brought suit. so here the ACLU was tripped up over a technical detail, not because a judge ruled on their suit's claims lacking merit.
. . And suddenly the world turned asymmetrical. There were no longer any battle fronts. It was every man for himself.
Interesting. Why did this take so long? The first thing to be decided in every court case is if the court has jurisdiction and if the parties have standing.
What?
You may come upon my body in a ditch but by God I will be laying in a pile of brass.
Quote: The_Nevadan wrote in post #6Interesting. Why did this take so long? The first thing to be decided in every court case is if the court has jurisdiction and if the parties have standing.
Agree. The lawsuit should not have been filed until the complaintant was a resident of Dixie County.